The judgement has been given in department's favour by referring Kolkata cat case. Kolkata case sought for parity with Inspector. Chennai case did not seek parity with Inspector.
In chennai case department could not answer the issue of person getting more on Macp itself than on promotion.
With the legal battle being lengthy, with no monetary or moral support, I am helpless and decided to drop idea of going further to higher forums of law on appeal. The judgement is available in Chennai CAT website.
